Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Are ice ages caused by Global Warming? According to the Warmers they are.

Anthony Watts notes that not only is there more snow, but the snowline seems to be moving south. But this too--despite previous statements that a more southerly snowline is consistent with ice ages--is now being attributed to Global Warming:

Some people have been claiming that the anomalous snow this winter is due to warming temperatures. The New York Times reports on the record snow :

Most climate scientists respond that the ferocious storms are consistent with forecasts that a heating planet will produce more frequent and more intense weather events.

It doesn’t make a lot of sense that warming temperatures would cause the snow line to move south. Lower latitudes normally receive rain rather than snow, because the air is already too warm for snow. Further warming would be expected to move the snow line north – not south – and that is exactly what the climate models predict. Indeed, Time Magazine claims that this has already happened: “large-scale cold-weather storm systems have gradually tracked to the north in the U.S. over the past 50 years.”

As far as snow depth goes, Washington D.C. recently broke their 1899 snow record of 54.4 inches and now has a new record of 54.9 inches. We are told that the new record is due to “extreme weather” caused by “global warming.” If so, what caused the nearly identical “extreme weather” over a century ago? Alarmists tell us that heavy snow used to be caused by cold, but now is caused by warmth. The 1899 record was set long before the hockey stick brought temperatures to “unprecedented levels.”

Now lets take their poor logic one step further. Ice ages occur when the snow line moves very far south. If “most climate scientists” are claiming that global warming is causing the snow line to move south, then the logical corollary is that ice ages are caused by further warming temperatures. Clearly that is not true.

Ouch.

2 comments:

Art said...

Now lets take their poor logic one step further. Ice ages occur when the snow line moves very far south. If “most climate scientists” are claiming that global warming is causing the snow line to move south, then the logical corollary is that ice ages are caused by further warming temperatures. Clearly that is not true.

Anthony Watts is striving to be the Demarcus Cousins of erroneous, um, writing. You know, just as Cousins packs a whole lot of stats into a few minutes, Watts packs quite a bit of error and fabrication into a few lines.

This pattern - whopping error and blatant fabrication - seems to be a common theme amongst deniers of climate change.

Lee said...

What errors?